Week 3: Intellectual and Legal Foundations
The Hammer of Witches

Image right: A torture scene from the Wickiana. Torture of the wife and daughter of the teamster Hans Ueli, 1577. The wife is being tortured with strappado. Source: Wikimedia Commons. Read for discussion in class: Oldridge, chapter 4.

I. Discussion: The Malleus Maleficarum

II. Intellectual Currents and the Feminization of Witchcraft
A) Elite (Male) and Popular (Female) Magic
1. The Rise of Learned Magic in the Late Middle Ages
2. Conflating Sorcery and Common Magic
B) From the Seven Deadly Sins to the Ten Commandments
1. Sins against Community versus Sins against God
2. The Transformation of Satan

The Seven Deadly Sins:
Wrath (Ira), Lust (Luxuria), Vanity (Superbia), Sloth (Accidia), Gluttony (Gula), Avarice (Avaritia), Envy (Invidia).


Image: The so-called "Madrid tabletop," by Hieronymous Bosch (c. 1453-1525). On panel, 120 x 150 cm. Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid. Source: boschuniverse.org. In this painting, Bosch sought to describe the late medieval conception of sin. The central element is the all seeing eye of God, with Christ positioned at the center, in its pupil, giving a blessing; beneath him is the legend, Cave, Cave, Dominus videt (Beware, beware, the Lord sees [all]). Around the pupil are arrayed the seven deadly sins with their Latin names. The four corners of the panel are decorated with scenes of the Four Last Things: Death (top left), the Last Judgment (top right), Hell (bottom left), and Heaven (bottom right) [for more information, go to boschuniverse.org].


CCC1565What Was Inquisition?

Read for discussion in class: excerpts from The Constitutio Criminalis Carolina (1532) [Canvas]. Image: Titlepage of the 1565 edition of the Constitutio Criminalis Carolina (Frankfurt, 1559).

I. The Legal Foundations of Witch-Hunting
A) Radical Departures: From Ordeal to "Inquisition"
1. Separation of Judicial Truth-Seeking from Judgment
2. Vesting the State: Prosecution ex officio
B) Abolishing Ordeal

II. What Was Inquisition?

Varieties of Ordeal and Torture

III. Discussion: The Constitutio Criminalis Carolina

An Inquisition Flowchart

IV. Where Did Inquisition Come From?
A) The Revival of Roman Law
B) Combatting Heresy
C) Secular Jurisdiction

V. Inquisition and Witchcraft
A) Witchcraft as 'crimen exceptum': Naming Accomplices and Unrestricted Torture
B) The Malleus maleficarum and Witchcraft Prosecution


Images: Left: "De quaestione, sive tortura (Von der peinlichen Frage oder der Tortur)"; right: "De repetitione quaestionibus, sive torturae (Von der Wiederholung der peinlichen Frage oder Tortur); both from Joost de Damhouder, Praxis rerum criminalium iconibus illustrata (Antwerp: Beller, 1562), Bayerische Staatsbibliothek (BSB), 4 crim. 43. Source: historicum.net.


Go to Week 4