Ordinary Men?

Image right: A German policeman publicly humiliates a Jew in the Zawiercie ghetto by shaving his beard. In 1939 there were approximately 7,000 Jews in Zawiercie. On 2 September 1939 about 2,000 of them fled as German troops occupied the city. During the first days of the occupation all Jewish males between the ages of 17 and 50 were ordered to assemble in the market square. They were detained and tortured for nine days before being released. A formal ghetto was established in Zawiercie in the summer of 1940. That fall about 500 young Jews were deported to labor camps in Germany. In a deportation action that took place in May 1942 approximately 2,000 Jews were sent to Auschwitz. The ghetto was finally liquidated on 26 August 1943, when most of the remaining Jews were deported to Auschwitz. During the deportation action 100 Jews were shot on the spot. The 500 remaining Jews were kept at the newly established Zawiercie labor camp, which was subsequently liquidated on 17 October 1943. Image source: USHMM, courtesy of Benjamin Meed.

Read for discussion in class: Bergen, War & Genocide, chapter 8; and
• Christopher Browning, Ordinary Men: Police Battalion 101 and the Holocaust in Poland [entire]

I. Discussion: Browning, Ordinary Men

Map: The Routes of Einsatzgruppen in the USSR, 1941
Graphic: The Pace of Executions in Lithuania

II. Film: Obedience (1969)

III. The Holocaust and Public Opinion in Germany
A. Who Knew What, and When?
1. Relatively Public KillingKnowledge of Deportations, Ghettos, and Open-Air Murders
2. Relatively Secret Killing—Gassings in the Killing Centers of Occupied Poland
B. Statistical Analysis: What People Recalled Fifty Years After


 Level of Knowledge of the Mass Murder of Jews Before the War Ended (%)

 

Cologne

Krefeld

Dresden

Suspected

11

10

13

Knew About It

27

27

29

Didn’t Know

62

63

58

Educational Characteristics of Respondents Who Knew About the Mass Murder of Jews Before the War Ended (%)

Education

Cologne

Krefeld

Dresden

Berlin

Low

27

24

31

28

Medium

31

34

37

24

High

24

22

22

30

University

26

24

30

41

Religious Affiliation of Respondents Who Knew About the Mass Murder of Jews Before the War Ended (%)

 

Cologne

Krefeld

Dresden

Berlin

Catholic

29

31

31

31

Protestant

23

22

27

28

Gender and Age Characteristics of Respondents Knew About the Mass Murder of Jews Before the War Ended (%)

Year of birth

Male

Female

Total (%)

1904 or earlier

36 (11)

37 (22)

32 (33)

1905-1910

39 (59)

34 (147)

37 (206)

1911-1916

34 (139)

32 (278)

33 (417)

1917-1922

31 (350)

25 (471)

28 (821)

1923-1928

26 (645)

25 (573)

26 (1218)

Total:

29 (1204)

27 (1491)

28 (2695)

Level of Knowledge Among Jewish Survivors (Before the War Ended) (%)

 

Suspected

Heard About It

Knew About It

Didn’t Know

All survivors

12

26

43

20

Survivors exiled from Germany before June 1941

15

27

32

26

Survivors still living in Germany after June 1941

11

18

64

7

 Source: Eric A. Johnson and Karl-Heinz Reuband, What We Knew: Terror, Mass Murder, and Everyday Life in Nazi Germany. An Oral History (Cambridge: Basic Books, 2005).