J385: Communication Law Home Page


 

Substantiation


"Specific Factual Basis" claim

  • The claim includes an explicit or implied specific factual basis for a claim
    • Scientific evidence equal to the claim must exist.

"clinical studies prove"


"Reasonable Basis" claim

  • The claim does not express or imply a specific factual basis, but does express or imply that the claim is supported by objective proof.
  • Evidence that will satisfy a "reasonably prudent business person" must exist.

"our hairspray lasts longer than the most popular brands"


"Puffing"

  • A claim of overall superiority that is (1) not capable of objective measurement, and (2) a reasonable consumer would not interpret it as an objective claim.
  • NO substantiation required.

"this is the best hairspray in the world."

 

School of Journalism and Communication